Sorry just skimmed through this topic.
If there's a tactic cap, then yeah no one in their right minds (if they're a leveling char) would want to get nk and -%. For those who does, there's always the option of adding -% NPC. So that would cut down the town pkers quite alot.
For guards to kill the people left who wants to get NK. You can't just give them a dmg based on hp % alone. A guard hitting 300 dmg on a lvl 1 is the weakest guard in the world. You have to give them a base damage then a % damage.
Also read here that anthem is crap. I agree. I say a priest should only be able to use anthem once every 10 minutes that or a person can only be anthemed once every 10 min. At the rate it is now, you lose 1 NK about one every 5 min, and with 20 NK a kill that's a hour and a half of waiting. Now if you get anthemed it's 20 min (still a decent punishment for killing someone).
Another suggestion I might add is, if your NK goes to about 50 and a guard(or even another player for that matter) kills you. I say teleport you to a "jail" (got alot of unmovable places in every town). Then you have to wait for your NK to reach 0, or beg priests to anthem you
