proeel wrote:My opinion:
I'm not sure about how desire robber work but I believe you will need missing hp to make the effect useful which is a perfect counter to st and ca.
Ca and st should not work on misses only if desire and robber doesn't work on misses as well. So these effects contra itself.
Regarding on the misses, I agree that they should not work. If you choose to use a candle or luck spell. You risk yourself for futher damaged from ca st. It's like a double edge sword.
Regarding on the ratio... I can't comment much as I think it all depends on the damage out put. Of course desire robber are too buffed at the moment on warrior as their highest damage and hp but if there will be future nerf on warrior. Maybe the ratio will be fine.
(Not saying from only priest point of view, as you may say st ca on priests are op as well but you need to realize that ca and st are also wear by warrior, which also has higher ac and high hp than priest. <= you can't claim that priests are the only one benefit from st and ca)
its work in this way,
Desires make damage based your your damage output, but not your personal damage, the damage that you deal to other person, for example, if i hit you with 1 autoatack a target and you deal 4000 hp with your autoatack, desires will make a % of this damage that you are dealing, g10 desires its 200%, so you will hit 4000 for your autoatack + 4000 * 200% with the desires damage, also the damage of the desires effect will heal you!! its like you are stole life, BTW you cant be full HP, if you are full HP, desires dont work.
Robber makes damage based on the HP of the enemy, no matter how many damage you deal, 1000 2000 3000 5000, robber make a damage equal to the max hp of the target in %, for example if you have g10 robber, if you hit a target and robber works, this will steal 21% of his hp, and you will gain the 21% of the target hp, same as desires, this need you have hp lost, same as the amount that you can steal with the % of the robber that you have.
whats the problem on those rares atm?, well same as CA or ST, this rares can hit with miss hits,
in my personal test, CA and ST are superior than desire robber, hitting targets with desire robber, aganist a target that have CA ST, the target with CA ST still more powerfull, (g10 CA =41% of your max hp reflect its insane).
without getting in a discusion with you, i just gona tell you that the power of damage of the warrior becomes for those rares, nerf those rares, will nerf the warrior already, but ratios of CA ST, desire robber, are a bit high atm btw i ill suggest you that make what kleis make here, make a post asking for nerf warrior and try to dont cry in all your topics post about nerf clases, here we are talking about CA ST desire robber, make a post with your suggestion of nerf a class propose the change that you want to see and then we can have a discussion there.
i think a good nerf could be fist make all those rares dont work on miss
once we analize the results of this, we can start to talk about the ratios of those rares
then we can go throw the balance.