GMSignPainter wrote:Titus wrote:" my vote is not positive" ( like cobos). 25 AC reduction after 5 hits its insuficient for me. If you want to create real archers/killing machines u cant tell them to hit 5 times!! to low AC and 2 more times to kill with extremes... someone who needs 7 hits to kill an oponent isnt a killing machine, is a joke instead.
As I said in the description, this is just an example, the value hasn't been defined yet.
is the reason i suggested something in between: ac drop+increase in ex damage also.
If not having a counter is the reason why players dont accept this idea i would suggest it gives additionally slow effect (bleeding) and has only 3 stack (-12ac per stack fro example) , this way i would not mind if it was possible to remove buffs with speed restore potion.. but all this could be tested.
I belive a good PvP could be when there is a counter for everything.
The problem is that there is no counter to high ac.. making certain classes like priest and especially warrior imbalanced at d4.
This is additionally making implementation of d5 more difficult since they would become even more overpowered...
Before suggesting desire or robber i suggest people to do proper homework regarding these skills.
Desire and Robber are combat effective only to warrior who has def buff pierce skill that is very strong in conjunction with desire and very effective robber thanks to conjunctoning tybern that increases his hp to incredible lvl.
I have written a bit about robber rares in this topic:
viewtopic.php?f=11&t=15693For the thickheaded people i belive gaz as torment current user brought the difference up quite nicely:
viewtopic.php?f=10&t=15927&start=140Gaz wrote: cell when he has sfd on him, torment hits him 1.7ishk x8 = 13k
Cell got 72k HP and 100+k with tybern
Cell can hit me about 11k
I can somewhat confirm this since with Thomas i hit 4k ex to random item wearing Cell that has no SFD or defence buff.
I have 180tt, g21,5force , d3 bow and z....
Edit: Chivas you can also read
viewtopic.php?f=10&t=15193